Jump to content
I am no longer developing resources for Invision Community Suite ×
By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans.

Recommended Posts

Posted

Does anyone know for sure when his contract is up? I am sure it is the summer. Can anyone see him being here next season? He is a good 4th choice but FSG are looking to reduce the age of the squad so he may well do one. Any ideas?

Posted

Does anyone know for sure when his contract is up? I am sure it is the summer. Can anyone see him being here next season? He is a good 4th choice but FSG are looking to reduce the age of the squad so he may well do one. Any ideas?

 

Dont see any reason for not keeping him. Seems to be happy being a squad player. No reason for NESV not to renew his contract. I think future purchases will be younger players, but he wont cost a fee so no worry about losing money because of his age.

Posted

I have no doubt he'll leave in the summer.

 

He's done a good job for what, £1.5m?

 

Certainly has done a great job for us and for the fee we paid. Id like to see him given another 12 months. Handy player to have in the squad.

Posted (edited)

rather keep him & sell the scrote for 3-5m

Me too. He offers something different to our current centrebacks.

 

Skretl doesn't really have any outstanding qualities the others don't have more of.

 

 

 

And from a moneyball perspective skretl has higher re-sale value.

 

 

Edited by epieur
Posted

He's done a job for us and I think he's better than Skrtel, but we should be getting 2 top CBs in this summer if we're doing things right so there won't be a place for him. I think Ayala and Wilson are capable of taking his place in the squad.

Posted

Think we only need 1 CB in the summer and can get away with selling Kyrgiakos and Skrtel

 

Johnson - New CB - Agger - New LB

Kelly - Carragher - Wilson - Aurelio

 

Kelly can cover CB and if we keep Ayala then we're more than covered there.

 

If we're gonna be restricted with the amount of money we can spend we have to spend economically so getting 1 CB will allow money to be spent on teh mor expensive positions.

Posted

I'd like to see us keep Andy Carroll's Dad for another season.

 

I don't

 

He's been a bloody good player for what we paid for him, both another year of him at 4th choice CB is another year that Wilson and Ayala are kept further away from the first team. Long term that's not productive

Posted

I'd keep him.

 

Carra getting older

Agger injury nightmare

Sktrel s****ness

 

This summer should be clearing out the s**** and bolstering our squad with top notch players, which should mean at least one quality centre half.

 

Personally if it was up to me I'd get rid of Skrtel first. Think we'll get back what we paid out on him at least.

Posted

I don't

 

He's been a bloody good player for what we paid for him, both another year of him at 4th choice CB is another year that Wilson and Ayala are kept further away from the first team. Long term that's not productive

 

If they are better than him they will be in the team. If he is better than them, then keep him.

Posted

If they are better than him they will be in the team. If he is better than them, then keep him.

 

There's a time when you've got to let the experienced players go to give the young players their chance.

 

Wilson held his own in the CL for Rangers - you've got to give him his chance or he's just going to stagnate.

Posted

There's absolutely no benefit in letting him go, if the young centre backs are good enough next season, then they will be selected ahead of him.

As it stands letting him go will require another purchase and another risk.

Posted

Me too. He offers something different to our current centrebacks.

 

Skretl doesn't really have any outstanding qualities the others don't have more of.

 

 

 

And from a moneyball perspective skretl has higher re-sale value.

 

If you're looking at value for money, Carragher would be the first you'd drop, as the highest paid CB (90k/w) whose qualities are more or less covered by the others, and moreover whose weaknesses go counter to the overall plan the manager and DoF want. Comolli has been looking at Micah Richards, a quick CB, indicating that the team will be moving away from the likes of Kyrgiakos and Carragher. And at their respective salary levels, Carragher should be the first to go. I personally think both can go, leaving the youngsters to step up, and Skrtel too can go if a top class CB is brought in, or if a youngster proves himself in any opportunities given. Whatever his weaknesses, Skrtel does have more of one quality that the DoF/manager rates highly than anyone else, pace. The ability to play a high line strengthens the rest of the team.

Posted

Think we only need 1 CB in the summer and can get away with selling Kyrgiakos and Skrtel

 

Johnson - New CB - Agger - New LB

Kelly - Carragher - Wilson - Aurelio

 

Kelly can cover CB and if we keep Ayala then we're more than covered there.

 

If we're gonna be restricted with the amount of money we can spend we have to spend economically so getting 1 CB will allow money to be spent on teh mor expensive positions.

 

Agger's still a bit of a question mark with regard to injuries and Carra's form is patchy. I think we need two top CBs to make a statement.

Posted

Agger's still a bit of a question mark with regard to injuries and Carra's form is patchy. I think we need two top CBs to make a statement.

 

When looking for top CBs, people need to take into account the story about Liverpool looking at Micah Richards. Rather than looking for great last ditch defenders, or man mountains who dominate the penalty area, the management is looking at a defender whose predominant quality is pace. From the players looked at in the transfer window, you can see how the team pattern is being planned out. Pace at the back, presumably to play as high a line as possible. 3 midfielders, with Dalglish being reasonably satisfied with the back CM options of Lucas and Poulsen, but wanting to reinforce in the passing department. More pace on the wings, but with Kuyt and Maxi filling up one of the spots as something different from the other side.

Posted

no reason whatsoever to let him go

 

He might want more than another year if that's the option when his deal runs out in the Summer, he might want to play every game

Posted

He might want more than another year if that's the option when his deal runs out in the Summer, he might want to play every game

 

i woudn't have thought so

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...