January 2012 transfer thread

New York Red · September 18, 2011

I'm just not sure. Plus of course it is early days and things can change a lot.

BUT...

Carroll -- Good player, lot's of raw talent, but massively short of experience. 35 million just seems like way too much for him. I can't ever see him being good value for money.

Suarez -- Worth every penny and much more.

Henderson -- I think he might be the worst waste of money of all. A lot of cash paid and a lot of hype. I can't see him being a good buy.

Adam -- He was cheap. I know he was terrible today, but he is just the type of squad player we need. Never a starter.

Downing -- He was expensive, but he is really looking good to me. At last he is with a good team and he looks like he will thrive.

Doni -- Cheap. How bad could he be?

Bellamy -- Two year deal. Good value also. Great record. Unless he goes mental I don;t see how he won't be good value.

Coates -- Too early to tell of course, but where can you get a starting CB for a top ten national team for less than 10 million?

Enrigue -- Good price, a clear starter. He'll prove to be great value.

I guess what I am saying is that I have some real concerns that we have wasted a lot of money on Carroll and Henderson. I hope I'm wrong.

honourablegeorge · September 18, 2011

This post is not viewable to guests.