Players of the season...

[floyd the barber]

so instead of the the boring top 3..how about top 10!

 

anyway......

 

1. torres

2. reina

3. gerrard

4. masch

5. hyypia

6. kuyt

7. skrtel

8. arbeloa

9. carra

10. babel

Edited May 12, 2008 by Lets get Masched

[goodrobotusses]

Torres, Masch, Hyypia, Reina, Gerrard, Skrtel

 

Those are probably the only ones who've played to a high enough level of consistency often enough, really. Others have had a combination of some very good games, or very good spells (ie. Kuyt in the run in).

[MFletcher]

Torres

Mascherano

Gerrard

Reina

Hyypia

Skrtel

Kuyt

Benayoun

Carragher

Arbeloa

Edited May 12, 2008 by MFletcher

[McBain]

Torres

Gerrard

Masch

Reina

Sami

Carra

Skrtel

Aurelio

Babel

Benayoun

[lfc4eva99]

Torres

Mascherano

Gerrard

Reina

Sami

Kuyt

Carra

Skrtel

Babel

Benayoun

[Herbie von Smalls]

=1 masch, torres

3 gerrard

4 skrtel

5 reina

6 hyypia

7 kuyt

8 babel

9 aurelio

10 benayoun

[Kahnee]

Torres

Masch

Gerrard

Skertl

Reina

Hyypia

Kuyt

Carra

Arbeloa

Crouch

[Cobs]

Tog

StevieG

Masch

Sami

Skrtel

Carra

Reina

Kuyt

Babel

Yossi

[Benitez]

1. Torres

2. Masch

3. Sami

4. Gerrard

5. Reina

 

Our five best and most consistent players through the season.

 

10's a bit of over-kill. Although you could give 5 extra places for Torres, cos he's deserving

 

Skrrrtel did impress, but he wasn't here for long tbf.

[Gunga Din]

Torres

Gerrard

Hyypia

Mascherano

Reina

 

 

after that there is litle to chose between any of them, apart from Riise, Voronin and Arbeloa who have been s***

[Guest Anders Honoré]

Torres

Gerrard

 

masch

 

reina

hyypia

 

 

Gets harder to pick beyond that. carra, lucas and arbeloa have been indifferent, agger, finnan, aurelio and xabi been too injured, babel and yossi too inconsistent, kuyt too average, pennant, voronin and riise just too poor. Skretl and crouch haven't played enough.

 

Think we need 3-4 from that bunch to excel next season like the first five have to make a genuine bid for the title. My money is on agger, babel and xabi.

[Kahnee]

Skretl (hasn't) played enough.

 

Virtually every game since arriving not good enough for you?

[Will]

after that there is litle to chose between any of them, apart from Riise, Voronin and Arbeloa who have been s***

While I think Al has had a disappointing season in general, that is an outrage to put him in the same category as JAR and Andriy

[Kahnee]

While I think Al has had a disappointing season in general, that is an outrage to put him in the same category as JAR and Andriy

 

Get used to it - Wayne is convinced he's abysmal

[Hassony]

Torres

Gerrard

Mascherano

Hyypia

Pepe

Skrtel

Kuyt

Babel

Carra

Yossi

[Guest Anders Honoré]

Virtually every game since arriving not good enough for you?

 

not when it's half a season.

[Guest Kaizer]

1. Torres

2. Gerrard

3. Hyypia

4. Reina

5. Alonso

6. Mascherano

7. Babel

8. Carragher

9. Benayoun

10. Riise

[MFletcher]

Skrtel's maintained a high level of performance since coming here.

 

He may only have played twenty games, but he's still had a better season than some players.

[MFletcher]

1. Torres

2. Gerrard

3. Hyypia

4. Reina

5. Alonso

6. Mascherano

7. Babel

8. Carragher

9. Benayoun

10. Riise

 

Mascherano sixth behind Alonso?

 

Riise in the top ten?

 

[crisps]

Torres

Mascherano

Gerrard

Reina

Hyypia

Skrtel

Babel

Kuyt

Carragher

Benayoun

[Kahnee]

not when it's half a season.

 

That's not his f***in' fault

[Benitez]

Mascherano sixth behind Alonso?

 

Riise in the top ten?

 

 

It's Kaiser the football know it all, what do you expect

[Guest Kaizer]

Mascherano sixth behind Alonso?

 

Riise in the top ten?

 

 

I dont think Riise has been as bad as people make him out to be, if you manage to look past the own goal against Chelsea I think he should be in there and he has been a much better defender than Crouch, Kuyt, Voronin has been as attackers etc.

[Shirohana]

Torres

Mascherano

Gerrard

Pepe

Skrtel

Sami

Kuyt

Carra

Babel

Arbeloa

[Kahnee]

I dont think Riise has been as bad as people make him out to be

 

Quite right

 

 

He's been worse