Before that match I thought that we had the perfect team and formation out there. With how City line up with so many runners from deep and Elano, Robinho and Wright Phillips behind the front man I thought bringing back Mascherano was essential. I've seen a lot of comments about how Rafa got it wrong today, yet I cannot recall anyone highlighting this before the match!! If they did, then fair play, but it's an easy game to judge after the event...