If Rafa brought back another Liverpool player

[Guest Snorky]

Rafa brought Robbie back the other year. If he brought another ex-Liverpool player back - would it be seen as a step backwards or would that depend on the player brought back ?

[magneto]

If he brought Owen back it would be classed as a sideward step.

 

Any other player and its a step back.

[Stevie H]

cheyrou!

 

[McBain]

Bring Baros back (on)

[Billy Dane]

Provoking discussion or do you know something?

 

Owen is the only one I can think of who he might be interested in, apart from Cisse of course.....

[Guest Snorky]

Provoking discussion.

[Chili Palmer]

If Rafa brought a player back he obviously thinks he could do a job for us. We have seen many times a move or a new manager can raise a players performance. for example (and I'm sure this isn't what Kev is hinting at ) if Heskey came back, I don't think Rafa would play him out of position and could get the high level of performances we saw in his first season with us.

[Stevie H]

whither danny murphy?

[Guest Snorky]

If Rafa brought a player back he obviously thinks he could do a job for us. We have seen many times a move or a new manager can raise a players performance. for example (and I'm sure this isn't what Kev is hinting at ) if Heskey came back, I don't think Rafa would play him out of position and could get the high level of performances we saw in his first season with us.

 

 

what part of PROVOKING DISCUSSION didn't register ?

[RafaShanks]

Digger?

[dorgie]

Joesmi could still do a job.

[Joxer]

So the deal for Owen is a runner then?

[Gomez]

Sissoko?

[Rimbeux]

Depends. If we spent big on a standout number 10 and a wide player of top class, then £10m for a poacher aint a bad price if that's what we need. Thing is, Owen is no more than that, not been for maybe four years. So you'd askk yourself

 

Is he actually good enough? One dimensional player, has to play in a two man attack, no impact in build play, for a 'judge me on goals' guy, not in the top bracket of goals per game.

 

Can he survive rotation? Could he cope with being one choice of three or two, and not first name down? Can he keep his form and his attitude?

 

Can the squad cope with his frequent injury breaks? Make no mistake they will come, and he wont get half a dozen games in a row to play himself back into shape/form

 

Does he compromise the purchase of better players?

 

Is he willing to halve his wages?

[Chili Palmer]

what part of PROVOKING DISCUSSION didn't register ?

 

I just don't believe ya...

[Falconhoof]

Barragan would add something as understudy to Finnan.

[Guest bigfooty]

I wouldn't be completely against Anelka coming back, so long as he wasn't the only striker purchased in the Summer. The same applys to Owen.

 

That pair apart it's hard to think of someone who would have a positive influence on the side.

[Guest Snorky]

I just don't believe ya...

 

But but but but................I've got an honest face.

[Athelstan]

Kirkland the obvious move. Should be good.

[Chili Palmer]

But but but but................I've got an honest face.

 

and one only a mother could love?

[Guest Snorky]

and one only a mother could love?

 

[jon_hall]

But but but but................I've got an honest face.

 

[Ombudsam]

never wanted baros sold

[Rushian]

Rafa's a fan of Anelka if it adds to the debate.

[stressederic]

Bring back Paddy Berger!