Ask him. EDIT: Though I suspect the answer is that there remain concerns, concerns shared on this board regularly, about the way we do our transfer business, especially with this summer ahead. He may even be mentioning it to act as a counterbalance to his strident criticism (again shared by many on this board) towards the transfer committee. They may have got x, y and z wrong, they may need to be renovated or scrapped, but they did *this* against the manager's wishes. He may even be making the point that this is hard, that there are endless wrong answers and processes and few correct ones and even the correct ones might only be correct ones for a while. Alternatively he could just be antagonising everyone. He does that too. So ask him.