On the basis of what I've seen from both players so far and on the balance of our midfield with those three players. I completely agree about his fitness though, Shelvey is only just coming back from injury and Spearing is fit, in the bigger picture however I can see only player potentially being good enough / making it wth us. If Gerrard is out and both players are fully fit then for the sake of balance alone it would make sense that Shelvey replaces his as he is more like for like, no? I think Shelvey could potential develop into a top player and I just dont see what with Jay, but as I said I'd love to be proven wrong as he is a local lad with a big, big heart.