Thats what I said! when he is playing well, i.e european cup final, fa cup final, etc, he leads the team well. its when he is struggling with his own form he goes into his shell and worries about himself too much, imo a captain must be able to see the bigger picture and regardless of the way he is playing himself should still be big enough to act a captains role, i.e encourage players, bollick them out, whatever it takes. I am not saying take the captains armband off him, I was just responding to a post that said he had all the qualities a captain needs, I simply don't think he does yet. BTW I don't see a problem with the guy that started this topic, its about Liverpools captain and he raised it on a Liverpool forum, he didn't do it in an abusive way, he just opened a discussion. If people don't want to join in on this specific topic then don't.