to be fair, i dont think you could really class Steve staunton as a "Star" player, the same, although perhaps a tad harsh, could be applied to Houghton. Neal is one i thought about, but i think he was more taken for granted than not loved, a bit like Steve Finnan today. one i was gonna mention, but is another strange one, was Jimmy Case. he always seemed to get a very "mixed" reaction, any tiem he came back to anfield as a player with another club