Both KD and DC have repeatedly said the former has the final word on transfers - as such he shoulders the praise and criticism where due. At present I'd say that Suarez and Enrique are clear successes and Carroll a clear failure. Personally I think Downing, while not being great, has suffered a bit by people not sticking the ball in the net from chances he's created. Adam is debateable IMHO, certainly as to whether he has the requisite quality to start. Henderson I think is too early to tell, Coates certainly is. In both cases I think the signs are encouraging. The big, obvious problem is that of the £100m spent on the four expensive players only Suarez is a clear success. That's a bit worrying.