In all godhonest opinion

[Guest Ant]

If so

 

A: What is it?

 

B: Do you agree with it?

 

Serious question

[Earl Hafler]

Of course not. No club has or ever will have.

Edited December 16, 2007 by Big Stuff

[Zoob]

It would be freaky if we did.

[surf]

If so

 

A: What is it?

 

B: Do you agree with it?

 

Serious question

 

 

A: BAN MURPH!

 

B: Absolutely!

[Mondavi]

If so

 

A: What is it?

 

B: Do you agree with it?

 

Serious question

 

im puzzled, clearly this forum proves we have differing opinions, what's your point ?

[Guest Ant]

im puzzled, clearly this forum proves we have differing opinions, what's your point ?

 

My Point is does the Liverpool Fan base have ONE unified voice regarding issues relating to the best interests of the Liverpool Football Fans, whose opinions influence those at the top level.

[Sion]

My Point is does the Liverpool Fan base have ONE unified voice regarding issues relating to the best interests of the Liverpool Football Fans, whose opinions influence those at the top level.

 

I don't want Rafa sacked

Someone on talksport did

 

so no. clearly not.

[Guest Ant]

I don't want Rafa sacked

Someone on talksport did

 

so no. clearly not.

 

Not the point I am making.

 

You are referring to the inner discussion, what about ONE unified voice, on ONE opinion, a organisation representing the match going and/or passionate Liverpool Fan

[Coyler]

My Point is does the Liverpool Fan base have ONE unified voice regarding issues relating to the best interests of the Liverpool Football Fans, whose opinions influence those at the top level.

Yes!

 

» Click to show Spoiler - click again to hide... «

Rafa Benítez

[Coyler]

Not the point I am making.

 

You are referring to the inner discussion, what about ONE unified voice, on ONE opinion, a organisation representing the match going and/or passionate Liverpool Fan

I think we would have heard of it.

 

Or the match-going and/or passionate amongst us would have, at any rate.

 

Is there one? Or is it a rhetorical question? If so, where is it going?

[Guest Ant]

Is there one? Or is it a rhetorical question? If so, where is it going?

 

My Point/question exactly.

[Mondavi]

Not the point I am making.

 

You are referring to the inner discussion, what about ONE unified voice, on ONE opinion, a organisation representing the match going and/or passionate Liverpool Fan

 

Still somewhat confused, I think the majority of the "sensible fans" have "sensible expectations", and "traditional, realistic expectations". There are however a not insignificant number of loons who think we should sack rafa every time we lose, and parry every time a rival signs someone for more than £15 million quid. That's the way it's always been.....or am I missing an obvious point you are trying to make ?

 

I think most of the "sensible" people are more reserved in their criticisms, and only speak out at obvious issues. The recent Parry political statement went right over the heads of people I thought of as "sensible" however, so no, I don't think there's any ONE voice

[Coyler]

My Point/question exactly.

Sorry, I meant "if it's a rhetorical question, what is its import?" not "if there is such an organization, what is it up to?"

[Guest Ant]

Still somewhat confused, I think the majority of the "sensible fans" have "sensible expectations", and "traditional, realistic expectations". There are however a not insignificant number of loons who think we should sack rafa every time we lose, and parry every time a rival signs someone for more than £15 million quid. That's the way it's always been.....or am I missing an obvious point you are trying to make ?

 

I think most of the "sensible" people are more reserved in their criticisms, and only speak out at obvious issues. The recent Parry political statement went right over the heads of people I thought of as "sensible" however, so no, I don't think there's any ONE voice

 

Good answer.

 

So if I was to say you to you, Right would you like to be part of a commitee which sole principle was to ensure that the best interests of Liverpool Football Club fans are observed regarding major decisons made by the LFC board.

 

What would you say to that?

[Mondavi]

Good answer.

 

So if I was to say you to you, Right would you like to be part of a commitee which sole principle was to ensure that the best interests of Liverpool Football Club fans are observed regarding major decisons made by the LFC board.

 

What would you say to that?

 

as a match going fan of approx 30 years I'd be in like flynn, I doubt such a committee would have the chance of making itself heard however. I suspect it would take 30000 people to have a chance of affecting any change, and I really hope the recent events don't escalate to a point where it's necessary, I'd hate that (although I think it's a minor possibility now, and have never thought that in 30 previous years).

[Guest Ant]

as a match going fan of approx 30 years I'd be in like flynn, I doubt such a committee would have the chance of making itself heard however. I suspect it would take 30000 people to have a chance of affecting any change, and I really hope the recent events don't escalate to a point where it's necessary, I'd hate that (although I think it's a minor possibility now, and have never thought that in 30 previous years).

 

Scale down the numbers abit.

 

Do you believe there could be a set of principles that could be abided by, all of which sole purpose is to have the best interests of the common Liverpool fan, be it someone from London, Warrington, Liverpool, Asia, America?

 

Principles which could be agreed to by every single member of this group, who discuss within themselves, and represent Liverpool fans as a whole regarding important decisions the board makes, be it Season Ticket prices or what not, however making a decision, representing the Liverpool fan within these principles, whatever they maybe.

 

A Well organised group, well controlled and moderated internally.

 

Regardless wether it is needed or not, do you think it would work?

 

An Un-Official, Official Liverpool Supporters Club, however in a much more complex way?

[Mondavi]

Scale down the numbers abit.

 

Do you believe there could be a set of principles that could be abided by, all of which sole purpose is to have the best interests of the common Liverpool fan, be it someone from London, Warrington, Liverpool, Asia, America?

 

Principles which could be agreed to by every single member of this group, who discuss within themselves, and represent Liverpool fans as a whole regarding important decisions the board makes, be it Season Ticket prices or what not, however making a decision, representing the Liverpool fan within these principles, whatever they maybe.

 

A Well organised group, well controlled and moderated internally.

 

Regardless wether it is needed or not, do you think it would work?

 

An Un-Official, Official Liverpool Supporters Club, however in a much more complex way?

 

Would like to think so. I believe there are enough "non 606 fans" out there to make something like that workable. I'm just not sure it could have a loud enough voice, and indeed could be subject to RTK type influence, which is not what is needed.

[Guest Ant]

Would like to think so. I believe there are enough "non 606 fans" out there to make something like that workable. I'm just not sure it could have a loud enough voice, and indeed could be subject to RTK type influence, which is not what is needed.

 

What if it where to be something NON-RTK?

[Mondavi]

What if it where to be something NON-RTK?

 

if it was about what the club stands for, what it means to the fans, what it's future should hold, as aposed to telling fans what to do, when to sing and other poxy s****, then yes that sounds like a worthwhile organisation, if it were heard.

[Kvarme Ate My Food]

f*** that

it would be a bunch of gob-s****s

[Guest Ant]

if it was about what the club stands for, what it means to the fans, what it's future should hold, as aposed to telling fans what to do, when to sing and other poxy s****, then yes that sounds like a worthwhile organisation, if it were heard.

 

 

Good answer.

[Mondavi]

Good answer.

 

i dont know whether to feel patronised or ask for a prize

[Knox_Harrington]

f*** that

it would be a bunch of gob-s****s

Good answer.

[sean]

Can we get to the point of this, I'm enthralled.

[Guest Ant]

Can we get to the point of this, I'm enthralled.

 

No