Jump to content
I am no longer developing resources for Invision Community Suite ×
By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans. By fans, for fans.

The 2007/8 Player of the Season game

Morse

By Morse
in Liverpool FC

 Share

Recommended Posts

Morse

Morse

Posted
Posted

The Liverpool Supporters’ Player of the Season game.

 

Hello everyone.

 

Some of you may know me. I am a visitor to quite a few LFC sites and have been the custodian of the player of the season game for 3 years now. The game has spanned 4 different sites in its time although last year the main voters came from Est1892, 6CM and YNWA. I am hoping that more voters from other sites will give a more accurate picture of our feelings as Liverpool supporters.

 

I am hoping that you will play a part in this 4th year to enable us to get a picture of our players’ performances and to crown a worthy winner come May 2008.

 

In 2005, Jamie Carragher won the prize. In 2006 it was Steven Gerrard. The 2007 winner was Dirk Kuyt.

 

Many people felt that last year’s winner should have been Steve Finnan or José Reina, and I admit to having some sympathy with this, but the votes were cast and the outcome was fair.

 

This year, the format will be different. Instead of voting for a single player as your Man of the match, you vote for your top 3. This enables a “steady Eddie” like Finnan to get his mentions and gain some points. (I did think about a top 5 list, but can foresee problems when the result goes against us…getting people to vote for 1 player is hard enough!)

 

Anyway, we shall see how the format goes. Points are the same as last year, top player gets 5 points, second player gets 3 and third player gets a single point.

 

All competitive games are counted, CC, FA, CLQs, CL and league matches.

 

I shall post current league tables so that we can follow the players’ performances throughout the season.

 

Hopefully, the table will put an end to the “Pennant is s****” type of arguments.

 

If a moderator could ensure a sticky when I post a Man of the Match thread, I would be grateful…also it would be nice if I could have a sticky league table thread for the game throughout the season.

 

Thanks for your support in this.

 

YNWA.

 

Stu.

Knox_Harrington

Knox_Harrington

Posted
Posted

Think it's a defunct system. The fact that Finnan was in the bottom half last season is all the evidence you need. You work hard on it Morsest1, I know, but it simply doesn't cut the mustard as a way of working out who was the best player across the whole of a season.

Morse

Morse

Posted
  • Author
Posted
Think it's a defunct system. The fact that Finnan was in the bottom half last season is all the evidence you need. You work hard on it Morsest1, I know, but it simply doesn't cut the mustard as a way of working out who was the best player across the whole of a season.

 

 

 

That's why I am changing the format Knox...read the post bud. :bleh:;)

Guest Kaizer

Guest Kaizer

Posted
Posted

This is how the Norwegian supporters club, www.liverpool.no rated our players last season.

 

Player: points- matches- average

 

1. Mascherano: 79- 11- 7,18

2. Gerrard: 332- 48- 6,92

3. Carragher: 327- 49- 6,67

4. Alonso: 313- 47- 6,66

5. Bellamy: 210- 32- 6,56

6. Agger: 262- 40- 6,55

7. Kuyt: 293- 45- 6,51

8. Sissoko: 155- 24- 6,46

9. Reina: 325- 51- 6,37

10. Pennant: 235- 37- 6,35

11. Finnan: 287- 46- 6,24

12. Hyypiä: 179- 29- 6,17

13. Crouch: 190- 31- 6,13

14. Riise: 261- 43- 6,07

15. Arbeloa: 70- 12- 5,83

16. Garcia: 128- 22- 5,82

17. Zenden: 121- 21- 5,76

18. Aurelio: 109- 19- 5,74

19. Fowler: 67- 12- 5,58

20. Gonzalez: 115- 21- 5,48

----------------------------------

21. Kewell: 13- 2- 6,50

22. Kromkamp: 6- 1- 6,00

23. Warnock: 26- 5- 5,20

24. Dudek: 30- 6- 5,00

24. Guthrie: 10- 2- 5,00

24. Insua: 10- 2- 5,00

27. Paletta: 29- 6- 4,83

28. Peltier: 19- 4- 4,75

29. Padelli: 4- 1- 4,00

 

As we see Finnan did not exactly reach the top here either, all a bit depending on the reporter doing the ratings off course, but I agree with most of it.

IgPig

IgPig

Posted
Posted (edited)

Did it make you weep when you saw his name above Riise?

 

Bellamy is too high also.

Edited by Post Kuytal Glow
Sion

Sion

Posted
Posted
This is how the Norwegian supporters club, www.liverpool.no rated our players last season.

 

Player: points- matches- average

 

1. Mascherano: 79- 11- 7,18

2. Gerrard: 332- 48- 6,92

3. Carragher: 327- 49- 6,67

4. Alonso: 313- 47- 6,66

5. Bellamy: 210- 32- 6,56

6. Agger: 262- 40- 6,55

7. Kuyt: 293- 45- 6,51

8. Sissoko: 155- 24- 6,46

9. Reina: 325- 51- 6,37

10. Pennant: 235- 37- 6,35

11. Finnan: 287- 46- 6,24

12. Hyypiä: 179- 29- 6,17

13. Crouch: 190- 31- 6,13

14. Riise: 261- 43- 6,07

15. Arbeloa: 70- 12- 5,83

16. Garcia: 128- 22- 5,82

17. Zenden: 121- 21- 5,76

18. Aurelio: 109- 19- 5,74

19. Fowler: 67- 12- 5,58

20. Gonzalez: 115- 21- 5,48

----------------------------------

21. Kewell: 13- 2- 6,50

22. Kromkamp: 6- 1- 6,00

23. Warnock: 26- 5- 5,20

24. Dudek: 30- 6- 5,00

24. Guthrie: 10- 2- 5,00

24. Insua: 10- 2- 5,00

27. Paletta: 29- 6- 4,83

28. Peltier: 19- 4- 4,75

29. Padelli: 4- 1- 4,00

 

As we see Finnan did not exactly reach the top here either, all a bit depending on the reporter doing the ratings off course, but I agree with most of it.

 

Because we all care what they think? Especially if any of them have opinions like yours.

Nathan Explosion

Nathan Explosion

Posted
Posted
You were doing top threes anyway weren't you? That's what people were typing in.

 

He was asking for the man of the match only - a lot of posters assumed he was asking for top 3 as that was we had used for the few years we did the thing on here, then dropped it because it was a waste of time, and it still lead to moans at the end of the season ;)

Leo No.8

Leo No.8

Posted
Posted
This is how the Norwegian supporters club, www.liverpool.no rated our players last season.

 

Player: points- matches- average

 

1. Mascherano: 79- 11- 7,18

2. Gerrard: 332- 48- 6,92

3. Carragher: 327- 49- 6,67

4. Alonso: 313- 47- 6,66

5. Bellamy: 210- 32- 6,56

6. Agger: 262- 40- 6,55

7. Kuyt: 293- 45- 6,51

8. Sissoko: 155- 24- 6,46

9. Reina: 325- 51- 6,37

10. Pennant: 235- 37- 6,35

11. Finnan: 287- 46- 6,24

12. Hyypiä: 179- 29- 6,17

13. Crouch: 190- 31- 6,13

14. Riise: 261- 43- 6,07

15. Arbeloa: 70- 12- 5,83

16. Garcia: 128- 22- 5,82

17. Zenden: 121- 21- 5,76

18. Aurelio: 109- 19- 5,74

19. Fowler: 67- 12- 5,58

20. Gonzalez: 115- 21- 5,48

----------------------------------

21. Kewell: 13- 2- 6,50

22. Kromkamp: 6- 1- 6,00

23. Warnock: 26- 5- 5,20

24. Dudek: 30- 6- 5,00

24. Guthrie: 10- 2- 5,00

24. Insua: 10- 2- 5,00

27. Paletta: 29- 6- 4,83

28. Peltier: 19- 4- 4,75

29. Padelli: 4- 1- 4,00

 

As we see Finnan did not exactly reach the top here either, all a bit depending on the reporter doing the ratings off course, but I agree with most of it.

 

Wow you Norwegians are generous - only one player with an average of over 7 and he played just a handful of games.

 

Who do you think you are with your f*cking michelin star.no ratings?

Morse

Morse

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
He was asking for the man of the match only - a lot of posters assumed he was asking for top 3 as that was we had used for the few years we did the thing on here, then dropped it because it was a waste of time, and it still lead to moans at the end of the season ;)

 

 

 

Correct.

Negative Knoxy... :bleh:

 

 

By the way, Pennant will cruise it this season... :popcorn:

Edited by morsest1

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.

Home

Notifications

PMs
×
×
  • Create New...