Exactly, I agree Suarez needs to score more but he is one of the only creative players we have in our team! Not only does he work his balls off for the entire match, tirelessly chasing down defenders and applying pressure he regularily sets up chances for other players (who atm appear to be missing all of them!). Last night he created at least two guilt edged chances for Carrol who did the usual and fluffed or wasnt quick enough (in body or mind). As others have said its not a dilemma anymore, Carroll is not good enough, he doesnt suit our style of play and he continues to prove that every time he plays. He is not mobile enough, lacks game intelligence and for someone of his size and build he very rarely wins a header even when he has a clear run at defenders (like last night). There have been comparisons to Crouch on this thread, If I could swap Carroll for Crouch I would - even when he wasnt scoring he contributed to the team and got involved. He was crap in the air but his ability on the deck made up for that, I hope we get rid in Jan. I am sure its going to cost us a few pennies but I dont see him being kept in the squad as an option - afterall he provided little impact when he is on the pitch.