Good post above, Rory. I agree with your conclusion about the riskiness of appointing a young manager, regardless of where they are currently working. What's interesting for me, and a nightmare for our owners, is that there are not any REALLY strong candidates this time, not like there were when we appointed Rafa. We could have chosen him or gone for Mourinho at least safe in the knowledge that they had been able to perform proper impressive feats at their previous clubs, including European AND domestic success with strong sides, but not the strongest. The current crop mentioned are doing well, they have potential, but they haven't demonstrated their ability to win major honours really - Deschamps OK, kind of, and Rijkaard with questions over how impressive he was given the resources available... I think it's impossible for us as fans to chose between them because there are so many unknowns - cultural issues, willingness to work in the FSG hierarchy, ability to handle a really big job - which can only be hinted at through contact between the board and the managers themselves. Who could have foreseen that Benitez would have been SUCH a good fit for us? Speaking of which... he has a lot in has favour compared to the names we are being linked with IMO... whilst I also think there is very little concretely linking us with those names beyond Internet chatter