I think I've said this before, but although JAR has many good points - his running, crazy goals and stamina - his lack of touch (especially on his right foot) and more importantly poor positioning make him a poor choice in a footballing side. Just to be clear, by positioning I mean the ability to know where trouble might develop in a second or two's time, where the oppo will be looking to go. Finnan has it, Didi had it like telepathy, and Riise has none of it whatsoever. As a defender he relies entirely on marking/tracking players, which against good teams means trying to put out the fire rather than stop it sparking in the first place. While we were a purely counter-attacking team under GH and early in Rafa's reign this didn't matter so much, as the back 4 hardly ever moved up the pitch, and once the defence got the ball, a lot of the time they'd launch it up the pitch, meaning lacking subtlety was not a problem. However if we want to play the ball out of defence, and use our wide players, we need fullbacks with good technique and the sense of when to overlap, when to hold back, and the reliability to play the ball short to our midfielders and not either sell them a hospital pass, or just not get the ball to them. In short, we need the whole team to make decent decisions whereever they are on the pitch, and enough technique to carry them out most of the time. Although JAR is a great athlete, I don't think he succeeds on both those points.