That first Everton penalty was never a penalty. The second was, mind. Don't think we could really have complained if Kuyt had gone, but at the same time I don't think they can complain that he didn't. If you get me. I've not heard a single person (apart from in this thread) saying that Gerrard's wasn't a penalty. He probably was looking for it, and as soon as he got the ball I knew it was gonna end with a penalty, but it doesn't change the fact that he was fouled. As for the ref changing his mind on the card, he only changed it to the correct decision. It might be a decent point if there was any argument that Hibbert should have stayed on the pitch, but no one - even blues***e - have said that he should