No, Gomez rightly pointed out that you conflated a very bad season with a very bad managerial performance. That's clear from your post saying he he achieved it whereas you're now softening that to he was associated with it. (Sometimes seems like you're prepared to die in a ditch over the validity of your every utterance.) On your no indication he would turn it round point: Rafa has shown, at Valencia, the ability to turn round a very poor season. So in fact, on the one occasion a very poor season has followed a brilliant one before in his career, the evidence shows he turned it round. Other managers, even other Liverpool managers, have had poor seasons and followed them with brilliant ones. Doubtless there were no indications during those seasons they could turn it round either. False achievement? Personally I thought 86 points with these owners and working conditions was an astonishing and certainly positive over achievement. Find it bizarre to see that minimized as a false achievement by a Liverpool fan. Particularly in the context of Rafa's other achievements both here and in Spain. To be honest this kind of false achievement stuff is more the kind of thing I expect from Redknapp Jr/Whelan.