I have given up on him now. I don't think he will ever be a sucess for us and I hope we sell him in Jan. He's so frustrating it actually hurts to see him play. For me the worst part is not his lack of technique or pace, but the fact that he's always on the back foot. No movement, no anticipation. He is just letting the game go by as he lurks around. How many times has a move broken down because Andy jogged rather than burst his lungs to get into a position where he could actually take part of the play? I genuinely feel that we would have been 6 to 8 points better off at least if Maxi had been playing when Andy did. Sorry, man. Your sheer lack of effort, passion and quality makes you anything else than a Liverpool player.