I'll ask the question again - If none of them played for Liverpool and I offered you 1 player to sign for an attacking midfielder / 2nd striker position out of Babel, Cole and Shelvey - you'd sign Shelvey??? Ok fair enough please explain though why I always write like a t***? What has Shelvey shown above Babel, Cole or Pacheco? If woy had made that sub and left Babel, Cole and Pacheco on the bench when he still had 1 sub to use - he would have been crucified!