I'm of a mind that says you don't let the players dictate the shape of the club. They play football - that's what they're overpaid for. Even without Gerrard and Torres who have made little difference to this campaign so far, with Rafa in charge we would not be so low - his worst time at Liverpool was still a lot better than this - in terms of play, points, goals for, goals against - the lot - much of the time without an injured Gerrard or Torres or both. Matt - you would be better than Roy.