The * is just me showing how ridiculous these stories can be and how fickle fans can be.... In truth I'm willing to give hin the benefit of the doubt until an official statement is released or there are direct quotes from the player. The only thing I can't stand from a player is lack of loyalty, have never got on the babel/Lucas/biscan/murphy scape goat brigade, but I have never really forgiven gerrard fir his 2 one night stands with Chelski, but I would never put down his contribution to the team or ability The one thing that riles ne about these stories (provinding they are true) is every interview he has ever dine is how commuted he is to the club... It just shows no matter how genuine a player seems its just standard scripted bull s***. (the exception being carra s bigger club - nah quote For the record I didn't say he was accountable for no trophies but as a member of the TEAM he has made an individual contribution (or not when injured. ) Appologise in advance if this is difficult to read but typed on my iPhone.