how many of the current liverpool team

[Hassony]

can be regarded as true all time liverpool legends?

 

IMO Gerrard, Fowler, carra, Hyypia and maybe hamman?

Edited February 22, 2006 by Hassony

[Huyton_Red]

You didnt mention carragher - that renders your views invalid

[Hassony]

You didnt mention carragher - that renders your views invalid

so who is this Carra that i mentioned then?

[Leo No.8]

Agree with the original list, but I'd actually say Dudek as well after Istanbul. He'll go down in Liverpool legend for all time, even if he never plays for us again.

 

Which players do you reckon will eventually go down as Liverpool legends in years to come?

 

I'd say Reina and Alonso myself...

[Hassony]

Which players do you reckon will eventually go down as Liverpool legends in years to come?

 

I'd say Reina and Alonso myself...

i agree with Pepe and alonso, maybe also Sissoko

[Guest Ant]

Carra, Hyypia, Gerrard, Fowler, Hamman, Dudek

[Guest AnfieldGrass]

Finnan will be a legend in the same mould as jock.

[AE]

Finnan will be a legend in the same mould as jock.

 

 

More like Whelan IMO, an underrated player who's value to the team is rather greater than many people believe.

[Guest ziggystardust]

More like Whelan IMO, an underrated player who's value to the team is rather greater than many people believe.

 

i always thought ronnie whelan was made to look better than he actually was because of how good the team was, like butt at united. He did score some screaming goals but he wasnt as good as people made him out to be.

[AE]

i always thought ronnie whelan was made to look better than he actually was because of how good the team was, like butt at united. He did score some screaming goals but he wasnt as good as people made him out to be.

 

 

Which validates my comment............

fast forward 20 years.......

 

[Guest Jack Bauer]

Carra, Hyypia, Gerrard, Fowler, Hamman, Dudek

 

This

[Jarg Armani]

think the nail has been pretty much hit on the head early on here.

so what about recent (and recentish) departures? i'd say definitely gary mac and probably igor. for different reasons.

[magneto]

You forgot Champions League Winning Medalist DJIMI TRAORE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Boca]

Well if scoring in a european cup final counts then Vladi deserves a mention.

[fred milne]

i always thought ronnie whelan was made to look better than he actually was because of how good the team was, like butt at united. He did score some screaming goals but he wasnt as good as people made him out to be.

You could probably say that about someone like Ray Houghton but Ronnie Whelan? Along with Barnes and Beardsley, he was one of the key players of Kenny's great side of the late 80's.

[Guest Jack Bauer]

Well if scoring in a european cup final counts then Vladi deserves a mention.

 

Na, his constant under performing and s***tiness will never be forgotten. Still be mostly remembered for that goal though.

[Boca]

Na, his constant under performing and s***tiness will never be forgotten. Still be mostly remembered for that goal though.

 

He scored in the ninety minutes and a penalty in the shoot out. All this knowing it was his last game for the club.

[Nerik]

Finnan, Cara, Sami, Didi, Gerrard, Fowler already have that status. Xabi, Reina, Garcia have the potential to be up there too.

[Hassony]

Finnan, Cara, Sami, Didi, Gerrard, Fowler already have that status. Xabi, Reina, Garcia have the potential to be up there too.

I love garcia, but i am not sure he will ever be regarded as a liverpool legend

[Mad_Fer_It]

think he might be... but in the same mould as supersub...

if he continues to score goals and if continues to pull off his tricks

[floyd the barber]

i hope im wrong, but as good as finnan is....he gives me the impression of one of those fantastic players while at the club, yet forgotten the moment he is gone..

 

anyway from our current squad..

Fowler,gerrard,dudek,carra thats about it for me..

 

Unsung legends..

hamann,finnan,hyypia

[WillG]

Warnock . . . his lack of positional sense is already legendary

[Guest Anders Honoré]

think the nail has been pretty much hit on the head early on here.

so what about recent (and recentish) departures? i'd say definitely gary mac and probably igor. for different reasons.

 

you left out the outstanding candidate in Michael Owen.

 

Possibly add Henchoz as well.

 

anyone care to say murphy?

[Figaro]

Gerrard

 

Alonso

 

Reina

 

 

and Morientes after he scores the winner in the next CL final...

[Earl Hafler]

Ronnie Whelan - The Makelele of his time. The most commented on underrated player of his generation. Not to say he wasn't brilliant - he was - but it's not exactly a secret.

 

Gerrard

 

Alonso

 

Reina

and Morientes after he scores the winner in the next CL final...

 

Reina will go down as one of our greatest keepers. I've had my ear clipped for saying he's our best keeper in 20 years but that's what i think.

 

Of recent years i think Didi, Hyypia, Carra, Gerrard, Owen, Fowler and Dudek will be remembered as legends and will probably be joined by Finnan and Xabi.

Gary Mac is another possible.